top of page

Screw-Retained vs. Cement-Retained Implant Crowns: Which Should You Choose?

Writer: Dr. Divij Khullar
Dr. Divij Khullar
Oct 27
6 min read
Screw-Retained vs. Cement-Retained Implant Crowns

After an implant has been surgically placed and osseointegration is complete, the restorative dentist still has an important decision to make:


Should the final crown be screw-retained or cement-retained?


The debate around screw-retained vs cement-retained implant crowns has continued for years because neither approach is universally superior. Both can provide predictable clinical outcomes, but each has different advantages, limitations and complication profiles.


For general dentists restoring implants placed by surgeons, the decision should therefore be based on implant position, esthetics, occlusion, retrievability, soft-tissue considerations and restorative design rather than simply following a personal preference.


What Is a Screw-Retained Implant Crown?


A screw-retained crown is secured directly to the implant or an appropriate implant component using a prosthetic screw.


One of its biggest clinical advantages is retrievability.


If the crown requires repair, modification, inspection or replacement, the dentist can generally access the restoration by removing the screw rather than cutting through cement. This can become particularly valuable when managing technical complications over the long term.


However, screw retention requires a suitable implant trajectory and adequate space for the screw access channel. If the access emerges through an unfavorable area of the visible crown or compromises the restorative design, the esthetic and functional implications must be considered.


What Is a Cement-Retained Implant Crown?


With a cement-retained restoration, the crown is cemented onto an implant abutment.


This approach can provide greater flexibility when the implant's angulation would otherwise result in an unfavorable screw-access position. It may also allow the clinician to maintain an intact occlusal or facial surface where screw access would otherwise be visible.


ITI consensus notes that cement retention can be useful for short-span prostheses with margins at or above tissue level, for esthetic situations involving unfavorable screw access and when an intact occlusal surface is desirable.


But cement retention introduces another clinical consideration: cement management.


The Cement-Excess Problem


One of the major concerns with cement-retained implant crowns is residual subgingival cement.


If cement remains around the implant restoration, it may contribute to peri-implant biological complications. This becomes particularly challenging when the restoration margin is positioned deep below the soft tissue. ITI guidance specifically highlights the difficulty of removing excess cement and its association with peri-implant disease.


Therefore, cement-retained restorations require careful control of cement quantity, restoration seating and cement removal. The question should not simply be, “Which cement should I use?” It should also be:


“Can I reliably control and remove the cement in this particular case?”

When Does Screw Retention Make More Sense?


Screw retention may be particularly attractive when retrievability is a priority. Consider it when:

  • Implant angulation allows an acceptable screw-access position

  • The restoration may require future maintenance

  • The implant is in a high-risk or difficult-to-maintain situation

  • The soft-tissue margin makes cement removal challenging

  • The case involves multiple implants or a full-arch reconstruction

  • Future repair or component replacement may be anticipated


In the esthetic zone, screw retention can also be advantageous when implant position permits it because it avoids a deep cement margin. ITI recommendations note that when implant angulation allows, screw retention offers clinical advantages, particularly where access to subgingival interfaces is difficult.


When Can Cement Retention Be Useful?


Cement retention can be useful when the implant position makes screw access esthetically or functionally unfavorable. It may also be considered when:

  • The screw-access channel would emerge through a visible facial surface

  • Implant angulation is unfavorable

  • An intact occlusal surface is desirable

  • The restoration has a straightforward, accessible margin

  • The clinician can reliably control cement excess


However, cement retention should not be viewed as a way to compensate for every implant-position problem. If the implant is significantly malpositioned, the restorative consequences should be considered during treatment planning rather than solved only at the crown stage.


What Does the Evidence Say About Complications?


The evidence does not support a simple statement that one retention type always has fewer complications.


A systematic review found high five-year survival for both cemented and screw-retained implant-supported reconstructions, with no significant overall difference in survival. However, the type of complication differs.


Screw-retained restorations can experience technical complications such as screw loosening or fracture. Cement-retained restorations can have biological concerns associated with residual cement.


ITI consensus similarly reports technical complications with both approaches and notes higher rates of fistula formation and suppuration with cemented reconstructions in the reviewed literature, while screw-retained restorations showed more ceramic chipping.


More recent systematic reviews continue to show a broadly similar pattern: screw-retained restorations may have fewer biological complications but can experience more technical complications. A 2024 meta-analysis of all-ceramic implant crowns found no significant long-term difference in marginal bone levels, while reporting comparatively fewer biological complications and relatively more technical complications with screw retention.


Retrievability Is a Major Clinical Advantage


Imagine a patient returns with a fractured ceramic component, loose screw, peri-implant problem or a restoration that needs modification.


With a screw-retained crown, the restoration can generally be removed relatively directly. With cement retention, retrieval may involve crown removal, sectioning or destruction of the restoration depending on the situation.


That does not make every restoration a candidate for screw retention, but it makes retrievability an important part of the original treatment-planning discussion.


A Practical Decision Framework


Before selecting the retention type, ask:


1. Where is the implant positioned?

Can the screw access emerge in an acceptable functional and esthetic location?


2. How accessible is the restoration margin?

If cement will be used, can excess cement be reliably controlled and removed?


3. What is the esthetic demand?

Anterior and highly visible cases may require different considerations from posterior restorations.


4. How important is future retrievability?

Consider the patient's risk factors, restoration complexity and anticipated maintenance.


5. What does the occlusion require?

Evaluate available restorative space, contacts and the location of the screw access.


6. What happens if something fails?

Choose a design that allows foreseeable technical or biological complications to be managed as conservatively as possible.


So, Which Should You Choose?


The answer to screw-retained vs cement-retained implant crowns is case-dependent.


Screw retention can offer major advantages in retrievability and cement-free implant-restoration interfaces, particularly when implant angulation and restorative space are favorable.


Cement retention can provide useful esthetic and restorative flexibility when screw access would emerge in an unfavorable position and when the cement margin can be controlled effectively.


The goal is not to choose the retention method you use most often. The goal is to select the retention type that creates the most manageable biological, mechanical, esthetic and maintenance profile for that specific case.


Frequently Asked Questions


Are screw-retained crowns better than cement-retained crowns?

Neither is universally better. Both can achieve high survival, but their complication profiles differ. Screw retention generally offers greater retrievability, while cement retention can provide restorative and esthetic flexibility in selected implant positions.


What are the main screw-retained restoration benefits?

Key benefits include retrievability, easier access for maintenance and avoiding residual subgingival cement.


What are common cement-retained implant complications?

Residual cement is an important concern because subgingival cement can be associated with peri-implant biological complications. Cement-retained restorations can also experience loss of retention and other technical complications.


When is a cement-retained implant crown preferred?

It may be considered when implant angulation creates an unfavorable screw-access location, particularly where esthetics or an intact occlusal surface are important and the restoration margin allows effective cement control.


Is screw retention suitable for every implant crown?

No. Implant angulation, restorative space, esthetic requirements, implant position and occlusion all influence whether screw retention is appropriate.


Final Takeaway


The implant crown retention type should be selected during treatment planning—not as an afterthought when the implant has already been placed.


Screw retention offers excellent retrievability and avoids the problem of residual cement, but requires appropriate implant positioning and screw-access management. Cement retention can solve certain esthetic and restorative challenges, but demands careful control of the cement interface.


For the restorative dentist, the most useful question is therefore not “Screw or cement?” It is:


“Which retention design gives me the most predictable and maintainable restoration for this implant, this patient and this occlusal situation?”


About Dr Divij Khullar

Dr Divij Khullar

Dr Divij Khullar is an MDS (Prosthodontics), FPFA (U.S.A.), World Record Holder, and BPS Specialist | Ivoclar Switzerland.


Through Dr Khullar's Dental Academy, dentists can explore structured approaches to prosthodontic diagnosis, implant restoration, occlusion and treatment planning with an emphasis on clinically applicable decision-making.

Comments


bottom of page